35 Industry Organizations Push Congress to Renew CISA

CISA cybersecurity information sharing act https://pixabay.com/illustrations/ai-generated-lock-encryption-9123440/

On November 1st, a coalition of 35 business and industry associations sent a letter asking Congress to extend the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act (CISA) for another 10 years. Enacted in 2015, CISA gives companies legal protection when they share cyber threat intelligence with each other and the federal government.

In the letter to members of the Senate and the House of Representatives on the Armed Services Committee, the coalition argues the vital need for CISA to continue. This includes how AI-enabled attacks speed up vulnerability discovery and exploitation. And that makes fast and efficient sharing across industries and the government more important than ever.

A lapse in CISA would push companies to stay quiet. However, renewal is only half the problem.

Plenty of organizations can't connect the intelligence already sitting inside their internal walls, let alone across a sector. It’s critical for cybersecurity teams and the government to consider what CISA protects and what's riding on the December 11 deadline. At the same time, it’s important to consider why sharing more data doesn't automatically produce better defenses.

“I've often seen organizations where fraud teams are investigating losses measured in the millions, while other teams within the same company understand threats such as subdomain takeovers, digital impersonation, and synthetic identity abuse,” noted Darin Fredde, Senior Director of Technical Marketing Engineering for Ridge Security. “Both groups have valuable knowledge, but they speak different languages. One sees financial losses and suspicious transactions; the other sees technical indicators, infrastructure, and attack paths. Sometimes the intelligence needed to understand a larger problem is already inside the organization. We simply haven't connected it.”

What CISA Protects

The November 1st letter was coordinated by the Business Roundtable, a non-profit association based in Washington, D.C., composed of CEOs from leading U.S. companies. The industry associations endorsing the letter include banking, healthcare, energy, telecom, financial, retail, aerospace, science, information technology, operational technology, automotive, infrastructure, hospitality, software, wireless, manufacturing, telecom, and utilities—as well as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

The coalition seeks a 10-year extension of CISA. Funding would come from the National Defense Authorization Act, which is currently being debated in the Senate after being passed by the House of Representatives.

CISA currently provides a range of benefits to participating organizations:

  • Legal cover for voluntary threat intelligence sharing.
  • Sharing between companies and with the federal government.
  • The protections that legal teams rely on before saying yes to requests for information.

CISA has already been extended temporarily, but that time is running out. Should the act expire on December 11th, it’s unclear where organizations might turn for short-term fixes

The Ramifications If CISA Goes Away

Looming over the ramifications if CISA goes away is that AI has dramatically shrunk the exploitation window of cyberattacks. Cybercriminals have accelerated the time to discover and weaponize vulnerabilities. According to the Cloud Security Alliance, AI has reduced attacks that used to take weeks or months down to minutes or even seconds

And while there’s a lot of room for improvement for the systems that allow organizations and the government to share cybersecurity information, CISA is the vehicle to improve that sharing, which currently operates at a significantly slower, more fragmented pace compared to the machine-speed velocity of modern cyber attackers.

The stakes are too high to not continue trying to close the gap. Should a lapse in CISA occur, companies would have to pull back without liability protection. With internal counsel advising silence over sharing, blind spots would occur across industry sectors that depend on each other.

The Need to Go Beyond Sharing

Even if Congress renews CISA, organizations and the government need to go beyond simply sharing information to help each other understand cyberattacks and what it will take to thwart them. For starters, fraud teams and security teams need to speak the same language and connect the intelligence that they currently collect.

Another obstacle to overcome is the concept of ten systems repeating one wrong assumption, a fundamental vulnerability in cybersecurity. This is where shared dependencies, copy-and-paste configurations, and universal trust cause systemic risk. Instead of ten independent systems providing safety through diversity, they all rely on the exact same flawed logic. A single exploit can compromise all ten systems simultaneously.

To make intelligence more usable, NIST SP 800-150 serves as a framework for sharing relationships. For exchanging intelligence, the STIX and TAXII protocols from OASIS Open, as well as the MISP standard and the Traffic Light Protocol from the Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams, all work well.

In addition, as organizations share cybersecurity information, it’s critical they oversee the process with their internal governance and privacy safeguards—validated by an independent third party.

Preparing for a Renewal Delay

With the results of the midterm elections, many senators and House members are in lame-duck status. This could hurt the chances of a CISA renewal by December 11. If a deal is not reached, lawmakers may have to rely on another short-term stopgap extension.

Between now and the deadline, cybersecurity teams should re-evaluate their threat intelligence sharing. Possible measures include using private-sector channels for information sharing and analysis as well as reviewing data-sharing agreements against privacy laws to see which workflows no longer receive statutory backing.

It’s also important to scrub Personally Identifiable Information (PII). This includes ensuring removal of unneeded PII and sensitive data before statutory immunities covering accidental disclosures are no longer guaranteed.

Another area to focus on is edge defenses. Intelligence gathered from private and commercial feeds should flow directly into local detection, SIEM, and automated response systems—rather than waiting on federal feedback loops.

“The only way we survive in computer security is by sharing information,” emphasizes John Strand, Owner of Black Hills Information Security. “This program (CISA) gives us a way to do exactly that. Information sharing is key.”

Adds Fredde, “The greatest intelligence failure may not be what we don't know, but what we collectively know and fail to understand together. Bringing together different domains of expertise can uncover hidden knowledge, revealing connections and patterns that no single discipline could recognize on its own.”

 

Author
  • Jeff Pike
    Contributing Writer, Security Buzz
    After majoring in journalism at Northeastern University and working for The Boston Globe, Jeff Pike has collaborated with technical experts in the IT industry for more than 30 years. His technology expertise ranges from cybersecurity to networking, the cloud, and user productivity. Major industry players Jeff has written for include Microsoft, Cisco, Dell, AWS, and Google.